Starbucks' Unit Economics and Digital Proficiency Defend Its Growth at Scale Narrative

Equity Analyst

Sean Dunlop

North America stores

International stores

Store Count

North America

International

Channel Development

Corporate and Other

Revenue by Geography

Revenue segments as reported by the company.

Company-operated stores

Licensed stores

Other

Revenue Segments

Gross Profit, Operating Income, and Net Income as a percentage of Revenue

Gross Margin

Operating Margin

Profit Margin

Margins

An operating expense is an expense a business incurs through its normal business operations. Often abbreviated as OPEX.

Store OpEx

Other OpEx

Restructuring

Income from equity investees

Gain from sale of assets

Operating Expenses

Year over year growth in Revenue and Operating Expenses.

Revenue Y/Y

OpEx Y/Y

Growth

Shares outstanding refer to a company's stock currently held by all its shareholders, including share blocks held by institutional investors and restricted shares owned by the company's officers and insiders.

Outstanding Shares

Market Cap

Also known as Price/Sales Ratio. Calculated using Average market cap for the quarter / Annualized quarterly revenue.

Revenue Multiple

Starbucks is the largest specialty coffee chain in the world, generating $32 billion in sales during fiscal 2022. The firm’s attention to premium-quality coffee distinguishes it from chained competitors, alleviating pressure from quick-service peers and at-home consumption while underpinning substantially higher pricing for what has historically been a commoditized product. This positioning looks increasingly important to us moving forward, as both vending and single-serve coffee machines continue to improve at the lower end of the market.

While the subindustry has attracted significant competitive attention, Starbucks' cachet has allowed the firm to outflank competitors, leveraging its brand to raise prices 7.4% annually in the U.S. over the last five years, healthily in excess of category inflation. Commanding unit economics, with payback periods in the ballpark of two years (against three to six years in the broader QSR space) should pave the way for mid-single-digit unit growth through 2032, in our view, as the firm increases penetration in its core U.S. and China, and with its license partners in more than 80 other global markets.

Starbucks' near term priorities, as outlined in its reinvention plan, strike us as prudent: investing in the in-store partner experience, recalibrating stores to better meet the needs of an increasingly off-premises consumer, and emphasizing consistent guest experience across omnichannel touch points. With more than 70% of sales now coming through the firm's drive-thru, delivery, and mobile order and payment channels, augmented attention to back-end systems and throughput capacity appear cogent.

Finally, the firm’s ongoing investments in its loyalty program, with nearly 31 million active users in the U.S., clearly resonate with an audience that has grown increasingly amenable to digital ordering, with more than 57% of U.S. order volume now driven by program participants. We continue to believe that Starbucks remains a compelling long-term “growth at scale” story, with our forecast anticipating average annual top and bottom line growth of 9% and 14% through 2032, respectively.

Business Strategy & Outlook

Low barriers to entry and minimal switching costs render the restaurant industry very competitive, making it difficult for most operators to develop an economic moat. In our view, firms that are able to do so generally lean into a brand intangible asset or a scale-driven cost advantage, with those sources often arising in tandem. While brand intangible assets are often difficult to definitively quantify, we assess brands based on their ability to generate comparable store sales growth (price, mix, and traffic) in excess of category inflation, carry a banner to international markets, and create value for franchisees where relevant, while cost advantages often materialize through lower general and administrative costs as a percentage of systemwide sales and superior restaurant-level margins.

In our view, Starbucks is one of the few operators in our coverage that boasts a wide economic moat, with brand strength—evidenced by pricing power, attractive unit-level economics, successful international replication, and strong results in the retail channel underpinning a durable brand intangible asset. The firm’s ability to generate excitement and traffic, evidenced by impressive comparable sales growth in the core U.S. market, while spending less on marketing than category peers, reinforces the importance of the brand and its impact on results. Moreover, though we view it as a secondary moat source, we also believe that Starbucks benefits from an durable cost advantage, with its global scale allowing it to procure commoditized food and paper items at favorable prices. The firm’s scale allows it to leverage technology spending across a larger store base, generating efficiency improvements and cost savings through automated inventory management, scheduling, and a robust omnichannel ordering platform, while a strong loyalty program increases its affinity with core customers. Our wide moat rating implies the assumption that the firm can continue to earn positive economic returns (a positive spread between returns on invested capital and the firm’s weighted average cost of capital) for the next 20 years—a view embodied by our 10-year forecast ROICs of 25%, healthily outstripping our WACC estimate of 8.5% during that period.

Considering the firm’s brand intangible asset, we highlight five points that would suggest a strong brand—the firm's pricing power, restaurant-level profitability, successful international replication, strength in the retail channel, and lower marketing spending relative to peers. Starbucks’ position as a premium vendor of coffee, tea, and refresher beverages is widely recognized, as it has historically managed its positioning to avoid finding itself caught between discount competitors like Dunkin’ and McDonald’s McCafé platform on the low end and specialty independent shops on the high end of the market. Strong increases in average check, up just north of 7% per year in the U.S. market since 2018, attest to the firm’s ability to continue to push menu price increases, larger drink sizes, and premium customized beverages (modifiers like an extra pump of syrup or shot of espresso have purportedly grown to a $1 billion platform on their own, to this effect). An average ticket of $7.79 in 2021, based on Morningstar estimates and Euromonitor data, outpaced peers like Caribou Coffee ($6.17), Dunkin’ ($3.92), and Luckin Coffee (around $2), corroborating our thesis. While pricing power is generally less pronounced in the grocery channel, we note that narrow-moat Kroger's management has identified Starbucks’ packaged coffee and other premium offerings as bellwethers for consumer health in the past, implying that the firm operates at higher price points than other category players, such as Folgers, Maxwell House, and JDE Peet's. 

Pivoting to unit economics, Starbucks' cash-on-cash returns offer one of the highest returns on investment in our coverage for franchisees, with management estimating roughly 50% cash-on-cash returns in the U.S. and close to 70% in China preroyalty—suggesting 1-2 year payback periods. The firm's restaurant margins oscillate meaningfully, but with median margins in the high-teens over the past five years and with average unit sales north of $2 million at company-owned stores, we back into roughly $370,000 in average restaurant-level operating profit—and considering competitive buildout costs, given the lack of a full kitchenette at the coffee chain's units, we believe that management's estimates are faithful. The firm's two-year payback figure stacks up remarkably against a QSR industry average of 4-6 years, suggesting that multibrand license partners are more likely to funnel discretionary capital into new Starbucks units than competitive brands with a lower ROI, and generally permits that Starbucks is able to seek out the most reputable and best capitalized license partners in the markets in which it operates—an important undertaking as the firm seeks to maintain its premium positioning and global brand cachet. 

Turning to that global positioning, we view international replication as another pillar of our restaurant intangible asset framework, with strong international uptake and concept portability indicating brand recognition, strength, and product quality. Starbucks operated or licensed more than 18,000 international stores at the end of fiscal 2022, featuring operations in more than 80 global markets. The brand’s reach is matched only by McDonald’s and KFC among chained restaurants worldwide, and potential expansion through the global coffee alliance partnership with wide-moat Nestlé could result in further international opportunities as the consumer packaged goods behemoth has a 190-country footprint. Considering this channel, we appreciate Starbucks’ ability to amplify its brand with premium offerings such as packaged coffees, ready-to-drink beverages, single-serve products such Nespresso pods, instant coffee, and a variety of related items. While the firm saw revenue through this channel decline in each of the last two years, concomitant with more royalty-based agreements, we believe that the firm's long-standing bottling partnership with PepsiCo increases its distribution and manufacturing capability, while the global coffee alliance joint venture has allowed Starbucks to quickly expand into new international markets by leveraging the European firm’s unrivaled network of distribution touch points globally. With distribution and shelf space representing the biggest bottlenecks in the grocery channel, we believe that Nestlé’s entrenched distribution relationships, role as a channel captain, and ability to operate with lower costs as it delivers larger case sizes to retail partners (due to cross-selling) are extremely attractive, while premium shelf placement should see inventories turn faster and in turn become more alluring to retail partners.

Finally, while lower marketing costs as a percentage of sales (averaging 1.1% of sales over the last five years, relative to McDonald’s 4% marketing royalty rate and Dunkin’s 5%) could be construed as a cost advantage, we believe that it more accurately reflects brand strength, as Starbucks has been able to generate buzz and sales volume despite a tighter marketing budget—corroborating our thesis that the firm’s cost advantage is a secondary moat source, subordinate to the strength of its brand intangible asset.

Nonetheless, we believe that Starbucks features a durable and stand-alone cost advantage, with the company’s global scale and strong unit volumes allowing it to benefit from procurement discounts, while strong systemwide sales provide natural operating leverage over fixed investments in technology and product research and development. With revenue of $26.6 billion through company-owned stores around the world in fiscal 2022 (and an undisclosed amount through more than 16,700 licensed stores), Starbucks is one of the largest global restaurant chains, with systemwide sales likely falling somewhere between Restaurant Brands International ($39 billion in 2022) and Yum Brands ($59 billion in 2022). Only McDonald’s, with $116 billion in 2022 systemwide sales handily outpaces Starbucks’ global reach. As a result, we believe that centralized purchasing allows the firm to take advantage of volume discounts on everything from Mastrena espresso machines to commoditized staples like milk, eggs, syrups, and pastry items, which are subsequently distributed across the company-operated and licensed footprint. We believe that higher unit volumes and proportionately larger drop sizes lower the cost of servicing Starbucks’ stores, allowing the firm to benefit from volume discounts with food distributors and underpinning a durable cost advantage in a category that derives more than one third of sales from independent restaurants. As a final proof point, we consider the firm's commitment of $2.5 billion to $3 billion of capital expenditures per year through 2025, against a backdrop that has seen restaurant margins contract materially over the past year—an attestation, in our view, that Starbucks' scale permits investments in moat-accretive investment opportunities through the cycle, ossifying the firm's position as the global category leader during a period in which peers are widely pulling back on nonessential spending.

Further, Starbucks’ scale allows the firm to leverage large technological investments across the store footprint, with a recent focus on artificial intelligence-driven efficiency, yielding a new cold beverage station, a plug-and-play cloud-deployed retail technology stack for U.S. licensed partners, and new equipment for brewing hot and cold brew coffees. Other technological investments, including omnichannel ordering capabilities and the expansion of the firm’s loyalty program have proven fruitful, with 31 million active members in the U.S. utilizing the loyalty program and driving 57% of North American sales volume. The firm believes that loyalty program members spend as much as 3 times that of non-loyalty program participants, and storing ordering data on a proprietary platform affords the firm an invaluable database of popular item pairings, promotion efficacy, and even ordering tendencies across geographies, dayparts, and weather patterns. With an estimated domestic customer base in the neighborhood of 75 million (implying penetration of more than 40%), we believe that Starbucks has one of the most widely adopted platforms in our coverage and see strong upside in China and the Asia-Pacific region, where technology savvy customers have more widely embraced mobile order and payment options.

The importance of these technological investments is difficult to overstate. Targeted promotional activity allows the firm to charge consumers different prices without cheapening the brand, while limited-time offers and promotional activity can help drive volumes across dayparts and toward underutilized days of the week or times of day. Marketing campaigns can be measured, adjusted, and deployed in real time, while consumer ordering preferences can quickly offer insights into popular menu categories that garner line extensions and further attention. Proximity to and relationship with customers represents one of the key links in the food-service value chain that cannot be commoditized, and a heightened attention to shifting demand—few would have foreseen cold drinks representing nearly three quarters of the beverage mix, for example—offers a tremendous competitive edge.

Wide

Economic Moat

Starbucks

Teavana is an American tea company. On December 31, 2012, Starbucks acquired Teavana in a deal with an estimated value of $620 million.

Teavana

Ethos Water is a brand of bottled water with a social mission of "helping children get clean water." Ethos water is manufactured by PepsiCo, & Safeway's Lucerne brand, but unlike other Pepsi products, Ethos bottles do not contain recycled plastic. In 2005, Starbucks purchased the company for $8 million

Ethos Water

The Starbucks app for iPhone makes it fast and easy to pay for your favorite drinks and food. Order on the way with Mobile Order & Pay and tip your barista. You can even identify the songs playing in our stores and save them to a playlist on Spotify.

Starbucks App

Torrefazione Italia Coffee is a coffee roaster and retailer in Seattle, Washington. Starbucks acquired the company as part of its 2003 purchase of Seattle's Best Coffee. By 2005, Starbucks had closed all Torrefazione Italia locations. As of 2017, Starbucks continues to market packaged coffee under the Torrefazione Italia brand. It is widely available at Starbucks locations, grocery stores and other retail locations.

Torrefazione Italia Coffee

Seattle's Best Coffee is an American coffee retailer and wholesaler, based in Seattle, Washington. Seattle's Best Coffee has retail stores and grocery sub-stores in 20 states and provinces and the District of Columbia. Sub-stores can also be found within many other businesses and college campuses, including JCPenney and Subway restaurants. Seattle's Best Coffee is generally cheaper than that of its parent, and is marketed as more of a working class coffee compared to the upmarket Starbucks

Seattle's Best Coffee

Starbucks Corp. engages in the production, marketing, and retailing of specialty coffee. It operates through the following segments: North America, International, Channel Development, and Corporate and Other. The North America segment focuses on the United States and Canada. The International segment is involved in China, Japan, Asia Pacific, Europe, Middle East, Africa, Latin America, and Caribbean. The Channel Development segment includes roasted whole bean and ground coffees, Seattle’s Best Coffee, and Teavana-branded single-serve products. The company was founded by Jerry Baldwin and Howard D. Schultz on November 4, 1985, and is headquartered in Seattle, WA.

Earnings data Q4 2023

Revenue

Cost of revenue

Gross profit

Operating expenses

SG&A

Operating income

EBITDA

Net income

Earnings per share

Total assets

Current assets

Cash & equivalents

Receivables

Inventory

Non-current assets

Net PPE

Intangibles

Total liabilities

Current liabilities

Short term debt

Income tax payable

Non-current liabilities

Long-term debt

Total equity

Stockholders equity

Minority interest

Total liabilities & equity

Total debt

Net debt

Book value per share

Cash from operations

Funds from operations

Change in working capital

Cash from investing

Capital expenditure

Purchase/sale of investments

Purchase/sale of business

Other sources

Cash from financing

Change in stock

Change in debt

Cash dividends paid

Cash from other sources

Net change in cash

Free cash flow

BURNABY, British Columbia--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- #bclab--USW welcomes agreement that Starbucks will pay wage increases to employees at its Clayton Heights, Valley Centre and Dunbar Street stores.

Starbucks to pay wage increases to unionized Metro Vancouver workers

McDonald's

McDonald's is much more profitable. Starbucks shares are more attractively priced.

Better Buy: Starbucks vs. McDonald's Stock

Mastercard

Holding shares in a diversified portfolio of growing companies is one of the best ways to build lasting wealth. Starbucks has a winning formula that is delivering great results for investors.

Got $1,000? Here Are 2 Stocks to Buy for the Long Haul

Starbucks has developed an extremely successful loyalty program. It counts 75 million active rewards members globally.

75 Million Reasons to Like Starbucks Stock

Dutch Bros

Dutch Bros' growth has been impressive, but its valuation is steep. Starbucks has a powerful brand and a global presence.

Better Buy: Dutch Bros or Starbucks Stock?

Starbucks' continued success with its loyalty program is powering the growth story. The company's market-beating dividend can keep growing at a robust rate.

Is Starbucks Stock a Screaming Buy for Dividend Investors?

Apple

Activision Blizzard

Brookfield Infrastructure

BlackRock

Brookfield Corp

Disney

Home Depot

Microsoft

Nutrien

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

Texas Instruments

Visa

Some months we might appear to underperform, but you must trust the process over the long term to evaluate our performance more accurately. On July 11, my shares of Activision Blizzard were up more than 10% on that day. Each year, I do a complete review of my portfolios in December. I like to take some time off to reflect on the year and review my asset, sector, and stock allocations.

The ATVI Story - July Dividend Income Report

NIKE

Apple's ability to launch game-changing products and services will propel it forward. Nike's powerful brand recognition and digital push should help keep it growing.

Got $5,000? 3 Stocks to Hold for the Next 20 Years.

Coca-Cola

Kroger

Target

Unilever

If you found yourself indulging a bit more this summer, take solace that you're in good company. Indeed, our collective spending spree has shone a spotlight on the best consumer stocks to buy, a category that, while having faced the bitter brunt of 2022's bear market, has made a triumphant return this year.

The 7 Most Undervalued Consumer Stocks to Buy Now: August 2023

Advanced Micro Devices

Pinterest

China was the star of Starbucks' earnings report.

Starbucks, Pinterest, and AMD Drop Some News on Investors

China represents a tremendous -- and underestimated -- growth opportunity. The adverse impact of Starbucks' standoff with union-forming workers is fading.

A Bull Market Could Be Here: 5 Reasons to Buy Starbucks Stock.

Target and Starbucks decision to add café items to Drive Up orders, will garner appeal from the younger generations who frequently use mobile devices for order ahead.

Target's Brilliant Move With America's Best-Loved Café: Starbucks

Decision in federal court in Spokane, Wash., is a setback for legal activists who have sought to unwind companies' policies aimed at increasing representation of women and minority groups in the workforce.

Starbucks Prevails in Legal Challenge to Its Diversity Policies

Shares of Starbucks Corp. SBUX, -0.66% were flat in extended trading late Friday after a federal court dismissed a lawsuit accusing company executives and directors of violating their fiduciary duty to shareholders by supporting corporate diversity policies. The decision is a setback for one of a handful of lawsuits that legal activists have filed to reverse Starbucks' policies aimed at increasing the proportion of women and members of racial or ethnic minority groups in their workforces and contracting corps.

Starbucks wins case challenging its diversity policies

Starbucks has been serving food and drinks in Target stores for several years.

Target Will Serve Starbucks At Curbside Pick-Ups

Minneapolis-based Target has been looking for ways to boost sales after disappointing first quarter 2023 financial results, which reflected continued traffic and sales growth in an increasingly challenging environment.

Target Launches Curbside Pickup For Starbucks Orders

Target's Drive Up service has driven the retailer's same-day services growth. Drive Up customers may now make returns and pick up Starbucks' orders from their cars.

Target's New Starbucks' Drive Up Service Has A Latte Going For It

The Minnesota-based big-box retailer announced on Wednesday that it will offer the service at more than 1,700 stores nationwide.

Target to serve up Starbucks curbside pickup in bid to boost sales after woke backlash

Target Corp. said Wednesday that it will start rolling out its “Drive Up with Starbucks” service across the country, following a successful pilot program that launched about a year ago.

Target to start offering Starbucks drive-up service everywhere

The retailer began testing curbside deliveries last fall, and will soon expand the option to over 1,700 stores across the country.

Target Rolls Out Starbucks Curbside Delivery Nationwide

Target is adding Starbucks curbside pickup as it tries to sweeten the shopping experience, especially as consumers buy fewer discretionary items.

Target is rolling out Starbucks curbside pickup across the country as it looks for sales jolt

Democratic Large Cap Core ETF

Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund

Alpha Dog ETF

Starbucks posted its mixed earnings result for Q3 fiscal 2023, look into how ETFs with an exposure to the coffee house chain will react.

Starbucks Q3 Earnings Beat, Revenues Miss: How Will ETFs React?

Judge writes: ‘Fear of retaliation will exist unless Memphis seven, apparently terminated for their union support, are reinstated'

Starbucks loses court challenge against order to rehire union supporters

Amid market volatility, enduring investments are hard to find. However, a few resilient, innovative blue-chip stocks offer competitive prices and total returns over the long term.

3 Strong and Steady Blue-Chip Stocks for the Long-Term Investor

Monster Beverage

PepsiCo

Beverage stocks have been hot this year, with gains ranging from the high-single-digits to roughly 50% for names like Starbucks. While the gains are not distributed evenly, the leaders are expected to continue leading the market in 2023 and beyond.

News for Starbucks Stock (SBUX)