Equity and Credit Market Headwinds Continue to Pressure AMG's Flows and Investment Performance

Strategist

Greggory Warren

A confluence of several issues—poor relative active investment performance, the growth of low-cost index-based products, and the expanding power of the retail-advised channel—has made it increasingly difficult for asset managers running predominantly active portfolios to generate organic growth, leaving them more dependent on market gains to drive managed asset levels higher. While we continue to believe there will be room for active management, which is hard to do in an environment where an overwhelming majority of the flows are going into index funds and exchange-traded funds, we believe the advantage (when it comes to getting placement on platforms) will go to asset managers with greater scale, established brands, solid long-term performance, and reasonable fees.

With $635.8 billion in managed assets at the end of September 2023, AMG has the size and scale to be competitive. Having 36% of its assets under management dedicated to alternative strategies and 16% committed to multi-asset strategies and other products, the firm is not as heavily exposed to the impact passive investing has had on active equities. Additionally, its equity lineup (48% of AUM) is diverse, composed of U.S. equities (21%), global/international equities (24%), and emerging-market equities (3%). Limited exposure to the retail market (29% of AUM) and broader geographic exposure also leaves the firm better positioned than some of its peers.

During 2018-22 (2013-22), AMG's annual organic growth rate averaged negative 4.8% (negative 1.0%) with a standard deviation of 3.0% (5.3%), slightly better than most of the other active managers we cover. That said, we expect the firm to face stiff headwinds in the near to medium term, with AMG generating annual organic AUM growth in a range of negative 6% to negative 2% during 2023-27, leading to negative low- to mid-single-digit top-line growth on average the next five years, with adjusted operating profitability hovering between 30% and 34% of revenue on average annually.

Business Strategy & Outlook

We believe the asset-management business is conducive to the creation of economic moats, with switching costs and intangible assets being the most durable sources of competitive advantage for firms in the industry. Although the switching costs might not be explicitly large, inertia and the uncertainty of achieving better results by moving from one asset manager to another tend to keep many investors invested in funds for extended periods. As a result, money that flows into asset-management firms tends to stay there. For the industry, the average narrow redemption (retention) rate, which does not include exchange redemptions, has been 25% or less (75% or greater) annually during the past 5-, 10-, 15-, 20-, 25-, and 30-year time frames. Including exchange redemptions, the rate has been less than 30% (greater than 70%).

In AMG's case, the firm's average annual redemption (retention) rate was 21% (79%) during 2018-22, and 19% (81%) during 2013-22, well below (above) the industry average. That said, during the same time frame(s), the company's organic growth rate averaged negative 4.8% (negative 1.0%) with a standard deviation of 3.0% (5.3%), which meant the firm was struggling to consistently compensate for investor redemptions with new flows into its products. With it is likely the company will do a slightly better job over the next five years (given recent improvements in some of its investment performance), we believe AMG has (at best) an average switching cost profile when compared with the industry and our peer coverage group, mainly as it has not taken full advantage of its below (above) average redemption (retention) rate for its long-term funds.

We believe the more traditional asset managers can improve on the switching cost advantage inherent in their business models with organizational attributes (such as product mix, distribution channel concentration, and geographic reach) and intangible assets (such as strong and respected brands and manager reputations derived from successful and repeatable records of investment performance), which can provide them with a degree of differentiation from their peers. While the barriers to entry are not significant for the industry, the barriers to success are extremely high—as it takes time and skill to not only put together a long enough record of investment performance to start gathering assets but to build the scale necessary to be competitive. This has meant the larger, more established asset managers in the industry have tended to have an advantage over smaller players, especially when it comes to gaining cost-effective access to distribution platforms.

Competition for investor inflows can be stiff and has traditionally centered on investment performance. Although institutional investors and retail gatekeepers are exerting pressure on pricing, competition among participants based on price has been rare, aside from what we've seen in the U.S. market for exchange-traded funds. While compensation remains the single-largest expense for most asset managers, supplier power has been manageable as many firms have reduced their reliance on star managers and have tied manager and analyst pay to both portfolio and overall firm performance. 

Asset stickiness tends to be a differentiator between wide-, narrow-, and no-moat firms, as asset managers that have demonstrated an ability to gather and retain investor assets during different market cycles have tended to produce more stable levels of profitability, with returns exceeding their cost of capital for longer periods of time. While the more broadly diversified asset managers are structurally set up to hold on to assets regardless of market conditions, firms with solid product sets across asset classes (built on repeatable investment processes), charging reasonable fees, and having singular corporate cultures dedicated to a common purpose have done a better job of gathering and retaining assets. Firms offering niche products with significantly higher switching costs—such as retirement accounts, funds with lockup periods, and tax-managed strategies—tend to hold on to assets longer.

Affiliated Managers Group, in our view, has a narrow economic moat. With $635.8 billion in managed assets at the end of September 2023, the company has the size and scale necessary to be competitive. Having 36% of its total AUM and 51% of firmwide EBITDA coming from alternative strategies (which includes multi-strategy, market-neutral, and hedge products) and 16% and 6%, respectively, derived from multi-asset strategies and other products, AMG is not as heavily exposed as some of its peers to the impact that passive investing has had on active equities. Additionally, its equity lineup (48% of total AUM) is diverse, composed of U.S. equities (21%), global/international equities (24%), and emerging-market equities (3%), and generates 43% of EBITDA. AMG's product distribution is also more heavily weighted toward institutional (51% of AUM) and high-net-worth (20%) clients, who tend to be stickier than retail fund investors (and generate 50% and 15% of EBITDA, respectively). On top of that, the company is slightly more global than its peers, with more than a third of its AUM sourced from clients residing outside of the U.S.

Unlike most traditional asset managers, AMG does not involve itself directly in the management of investments. Instead, it looks to acquire equity stakes in successful boutique asset managers, receiving a fixed percentage of revenue in return. These affiliates continue to operate independently, with AMG providing strategic, operational, marketing, and distribution support. This arrangement leaves most of the benefits that typically come with running an asset-management business to accrue to the managers that AMG buys, with the company not even generating the typical cost synergies created by most mergers and acquisitions (since it purchases equity stakes as opposed to entire operations). That said, we think the firm's proficiency at investing in and maintaining relationships with well-respected boutique asset managers has provided AMG with at least one unique competitive advantage. Having initiated its strategy of buying equity stakes in boutique asset managers in the early 1990s, AMG has been working with and adjusting its business model for nearly 30 years. In that time, the firm has built out a target investment universe that includes around 2,000 investment management firms (each with more than $5 billion in AUM), including a select grouping of 100 core prospects, creating a pipeline of potential investments where AMG is generally viewed as the "buyer of choice" by the owners of these boutique asset managers. 

At this point, we believe it would be difficult for another firm to replicate much of what AMG has created with its business model; those that have tried over the years have struggled to generate the level of success that AMG has had with its strategy. We think this cements the firm's position as the buyer of choice for many boutique asset managers. In addition, we remain impressed by AMG's build-out of its global distribution network, which we think has gone a long way toward improving the sales growth of its affiliates and enhancing the impact that the firm can have on asset stickiness. We think the global distribution network can also make AMG a more appealing partner for future affiliates, setting up a virtuous circle that the company can exploit to its advantage in the long run. Looking at its competitive positioning overall, we think AMG is facing a somewhat more competitive environment for investment stakes in boutique asset managers, which puts more weight on its ability to gather and retain assets within its existing operations but would note that one of AMG's greatest strengths over the years has been its discipline when it comes to doing deals.

Narrow

Economic Moat

Affiliated Managers

Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. is an asset management company with equity investments in boutique investment management firms. It provides assistance on strategic matters, marketing, distribution, product development, and operations. The company was founded by William J. Nutt in December 1993 and is headquartered in West Palm Beach, FL.

Earnings data Q1 2024

Revenue

Cost of revenue

Gross profit

Operating expenses

SG&A

Other

Operating income

EBITDA

Net income

Earnings per share

Total assets

Current assets

Cash & equivalents

Receivables

Inventory

Non-current assets

Net PPE

Intangibles

Total liabilities

Current liabilities

Short term debt

Income tax payable

Non-current liabilities

Long-term debt

Total equity

Stockholders equity

Minority interest

Total liabilities & equity

Total debt

Net debt

Book value per share

Cash from operations

Funds from operations

Change in working capital

Cash from investing

Capital expenditure

Purchase/sale of investments

Purchase/sale of business

Other sources

Cash from financing

Change in stock

Change in debt

Cash dividends paid

Cash from other sources

Net change in cash

Free cash flow

Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. engages in the provision of asset management with equity investment. The company was founded by in December 1993 and is headquartered in West Palm Beach, FL.

Bassett Furniture

Celestica

Conn's

Group 1 Automotive

Envista Holdings Corp

Vale S.A.

P/B ratio is emerging as a convenient tool to identify low-priced stocks that have high-growth prospects.

7 Low Price-to-Book Value Picks for August

ATLAS CORP

Blucora

Value investing is essentially about selecting stocks that are usually cheap but fundamentally sound. Vale S.A. (VALE), Atlas (ATCO), Affiliated Managers (AMG), Celestica (CLS) and Blucora (BCOR) boast low P/CF ratio.

5 Low Price-to-Cash-Flow Stocks to Buy for Optimum Returns

Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. (AMG) CEO Jay Horgen on Q2 2021 Results - Earnings Call Transcript

Affiliated Managers (AMG) records a rise in revenues and lower expenses in the second quarter of 2021.

Affiliated Managers (AMG) Q2 Earnings Beat, Revenues & AUM Up

Affiliated Managers (AMG) delivered earnings and revenue surprises of 5.50% and -0.74%, respectively, for the quarter ended June 2021. Do the numbers hold clues to what lies ahead for the stock?

Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) Q2 Earnings Beat Estimates

Shares of Affiliated Managers Group (NYSE:AMG) remained unaffected after the company reported Q2 results. Quarterly Results Earnings per share rose 47.08% over the past year to $4.03, which beat the estimate of $3.83.

Recap: Affiliated Managers Group Q2 Earnings

Company reports EPS of $2.55, Economic EPS of $4.03 in the second quarter of 2021

AMG Reports Financial and Operating Results for the Second Quarter and First Half of 2021

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla., July 21, 2021 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. (NYSE: AMG), a leading partner to independent active investment management firms, today announced the appointment of David C. Ryan to its Board of Directors, effective immediately.

AMG Appoints David C. Ryan to its Board of Directors

Affiliated Managers (AMG) doesn't possess the right combination of the two key ingredients for a likely earnings beat in its upcoming report. Get prepared with the key expectations.

Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) to Report Q2 Results: Wall Street Expects Earnings Growth

BrightSphere Investment Group

AMG vs. BSIG: Which Stock Is the Better Value Option?

AMG vs. BSIG: Which Stock Should Value Investors Buy Now?

Affiliated Managers' (AMG) deal with Parnassus is likely to aid its financials and be accretive to economic earnings. Post the announcement, investor sentiments turn bullish and the stock rises 7%.

Affiliated Managers (AMG) Up on Parnassus Buyout Announcement

Is Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) a great pick from the value investor's perspective right now? Read on to know more.

Is Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) a Good Pick for Value Investors?

Affiliated Managers (AMG) reported earnings 30 days ago. What's next for the stock?

Affiliated Managers (AMG) Up 1.2% Since Last Earnings Report: Can It Continue?

Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. (AMG) CEO Jay Horgen on Q1 2021 Results - Earnings Call Transcript

Affiliated Managers (AMG) purchases minority equity interest in OCP Asia Limited in a bid to fortify global footprint.

Affiliated Managers (AMG) Acquires Minority Stake in OCP Asia

Higher revenues and rise in AUM balance support Affiliated Managers' (AMG) Q1 earnings.

Affiliated Managers (AMG) Q1 Earnings Beat Estimates, AUM Up

Affiliated Managers (AMG) delivered earnings and revenue surprises of 0.47% and 0.82%, respectively, for the quarter ended March 2021. Do the numbers hold clues to what lies ahead for the stock?

Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) Beats Q1 Earnings and Revenue Estimates

Company reports EPS of $3.41, Economic EPS of $4.28 in first quarter of 2021

AMG Reports Financial and Operating Results for the First Quarter of 2021

Affiliated Managers' (AMG) first-quarter 2021 performance is expected to have been hurt to some extent due to a decline in asset balances.

What's in Store for Affiliated Managers (AMG) in Q1 Earnings?

Conference Call Scheduled for 8:30 a.m. Eastern Time

AMG to Announce First Quarter Results on May 3, 2021

Does Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) have what it takes to be a top stock pick for momentum investors? Let's find out.

Here's Why Momentum Investors Will Love Affiliated Managers Group (AMG)

Ares Management

AMG vs. ARES: Which Stock Is the Better Value Option?

AMG vs. ARES: Which Stock Should Value Investors Buy Now?

Here at Zacks, our focus is on the proven Zacks Rank system, which emphasizes earnings estimates and estimate revisions to find great stocks. Nevertheless, we are always paying attention to the latest value, growth, and momentum trends to underscore strong picks.

Is Affiliated Managers Group (AMG) a Great Value Stock Right Now?

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla., March 22, 2021 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- AMG Funds LLC, the U.S. wealth distribution arm of Affiliated Managers Group, Inc. (NYSE: AMG), today announced that as part of AMG's overall repositioning of distribution capabilities for the benefit of its Affiliate partner firms and their clients, AMG is supporting a series of enhancements to its U.S. wealth platform, which will now offer a unique array of high-quality funds managed exclusively by AMG Affiliates. AMG has always provided a single point of access to industry-leading strategies managed by its world-class, independent partner-owned Affiliate firms, which have strong and long-tenured teams supported by stable business platforms. Today, by moving to a lineup entirely sub-advised by AMG Affiliates, clients will benefit from a streamlined platform wholly focused on AMG Affiliates' high-conviction investment offerings, including fee reductions across all the strategies involved in the transition. As part of these enhancements, AMG Funds will offer Affiliate strategies previously unavailable to the U.S. wealth market, as well as provide additional differentiated investment solutions by repositioning select funds.         “AMG believes strongly in the advantages that independent, partner-owned investment firms have in delivering client outcomes consistent with their investment objectives, and our Affiliate group includes many of the highest-quality independent specialist firms in the industry,” said Jay C. Horgen, President and Chief Executive Officer of AMG. “Over the past two years, we have evolved our global distribution resources and clarified our strategy for the benefit of our Affiliates. Focusing our U.S. wealth platform exclusively on in-demand strategies from our Affiliates will ensure that clients are choosing from highly differentiated products. We are pleased to further align our distribution platform with our Affiliate partners, and look forward to continuing to invest in our Affiliates through the further expansion of AMG's capabilities in support of their growth.”

News for Affiliated Managers Stock (AMG)